deanisdarkness:

Oh yeah. Their argument made no sense to me. Amy thing is kinda like a trigger for me bc its been brought up by Sam!stans so many times over (seriously, there are even fanfics about that out there, you know of the mean!dean/poor!sammy variety) and they always, always love to bring up her name even if it doesn’t fit the current argument. Dean killing Amy has been discussed to death in this fandom and no matter what, Sam!stans refuse to see the truth of that situation and paint Dean as some kind of horrible villain.

Amy was dropping bodies left and right, she wasn’t some innocent soccer mom, she was a killer monster. Sam was batshit crazy, he had recently tried to kill Dean, so it wasn’t like Dean could have trusted Sam’s judgement in this matter. As you said, Sam should have apologized for the whole mess, and he sorta did –as much as Sam can anyway. I actually loved that episode, it’s a pity that the show never used that writer again. (yeah, maybe bc Sam was made to apologize or something, Sera Gamble was in charge)

Also, Sam did get his revenge against Dean for killing his brain-eater monster girlfriend, didn’t he? Sam killed Dean’s daughter even-though she had no blood on her hands at that moment. She was a monster, yes, but she hadn’t killed yet, she was redeemable. I mean, Dean’s influence changed Amara, so maybe his words might have worked on Emma too, but Sam didn’t give Emma a chance bc he wanted to get back at Dean for killing Amy.

Of course, Sam stans never talk about the unfairness of Emma’s death, you know, since she’s related to Dean and all that.