bibrosbelike:

hastobealock:

luxshine:

hastobealock:

‘They’re wrong because I say so.’

Just keep ignoring the plentiful amount of canon evidence that proves YOU are wrong, like you assholes do EVERY TIME this is brought up, but you hand-wave THAT canon away, yet you’re also the ones that try to use canon to your advantage in every other argument.

Doesn’t work like that.

Sigh. That piece of fanon is a fucking hydra, I am sure.

The scene where they are with Joshua? It’s not ANY individual heaven. That one is the center of the Garden of Eden which, for obvious budget reasons, had to look the same for BOTH Sam and Dean (since they were not going to take the time to time to shoot Sam’s POV then Dean’s POV) .

In universe? it’s obvious that the Greatest Garden would look the same to both as they both have the same experiences with the Cleveland Botanical Garden (aka. a place which both of them would identify with a BUNCH of plants). It never says it’s a happy memory for both, in fact, given that it was a field trip? It pretty much assumes that Dean was not having a lot of fun there given how badly he was treated in schools where he was sharing teachers with Sam.

Now, whenever people who see the same Center of Eden are Soulmates or not, it’s never established. What we know is that soulmates share heavens (and I STILL think that piece of knowledge should’ve come from an angel, not from mr. “I’m just guessing” Ash), and that nope, Dean and Sam didn’t share a HEAVEN (not memories, but a HEAVEN. Obviously brothers share memories when they were raised together. We share a lot of memories with a lot of people, doens’t mean we’re soulmates unless Heaven is into poly orgies between complete strangers)

Again, for people so obsessed with Canon, they should totally pay attention to it.

THIS, THIS, THIS.

SLAY